CRIMINAL PROSECUTION BY CALIFORNIA CITIES
In California, the primary responsibility for prosecuting most crimes, especially serious offenses (felonies), rests with the County District Attorney (DA). However, a unique feature of the state’s legal system allows some cities to establish their own prosecutorial offices, primarily to handle less severe offenses (misdemeanors) and local ordinance violations. This delegation of power allows local governments to tailor law enforcement responses to their community’s specific needs and priorities.
District Attorney vs. City Attorney
The distinction between the two offices is primarily one of jurisdiction and the severity of the crime:
District Attorney (DA): A District Attorney is a county-level, constitutionally elected official responsible for prosecuting all felonies within the county’s borders, such as murder, burglary, and serious drug crimes. The DA’s office generally handles misdemeanors in unincorporated areas of the county and in cities that do not have their own city prosecutor.
City Attorney/City Prosecutor: A city attorney primarily acts as the legal advisor for the city government in civil matters, but in many cases also has the authority to prosecute misdemeanor and infraction offenses occurring within city limits. A city attorney may prosecute violations of local ordinances utilizing criminal prosecution, code enforcement, or litigation.
Scope of City Prosecution
Several California cities, often larger ones, have chosen to establish dedicated city prosecution units. Examples include Los Angeles, San Diego, Santa Monica, Pasadena, Anaheim, and Alameda.
The types of cases prosecuted by city attorneys typically include:
State Misdemeanors: Common offenses such as driving under the influence (DUI), petty theft, domestic violence, assault/battery, and certain weapons charges.
Municipal Code Violations: Violations specific to local ordinances, which can relate to issues like zoning, public nuisance, or business regulations (which can often be handled either as a criminal prosecution or a civil matter with administrative citations or litigation).
Infractions: Minor violations, often traffic-related.
For a general law city (as opposed to a charter city), the city attorney’s authority to prosecute state misdemeanors often requires the consent of the county’s District Attorney. However, in a charter city, the city charter itself can grant the city attorney the independent duty to act as the “city prosecutor,” a power that can only be modified by a vote of the local electorate.
Prosecutorial Discretion and Independence
City prosecutors operate under the same ethical obligations and professional standards as district attorneys, representing the People of the State of California when pursuing criminal charges. They maintain an ethical wall of separation from the city’s political decision-makers (like the city council or mayor) to ensure independent decision-making based solely on the merits of the case and the requirements of justice.
This localized approach allows cities to focus resources on crimes that directly impact the community’s quality of life and safety, working closely with local police departments to process cases efficiently and seek appropriate outcomes, including restitution for victims and alternatives to incarceration where suitable.
Contact us by phone or email to learn more about how we can help.