CALIFORNIA OFFICE OF ADMINISTRATIVE LAW
The California Office of Administrative Law (OAL) is an executive branch agency responsible for reviewing administrative regulations proposed by over 200 state agencies. Established in 1980, its primary mission is to ensure that state regulations are clear, necessary, and legally valid under California’s Administrative Procedure Act (APA).
An attorney experienced in administrative law can help clients challenge proposed agency regulations, and navigate administrative citations, disciplinary actions, and hearings while ensuring procedural rules are followed, evidence is properly presented, and legal arguments are documented for potential appeals.
Core Responsibilities of the Office of Administrative Law
The Office of Administrative Law serves four fundamental functions in California’s government:
Regulatory Review: OAL reviews all new, amended, or repealed regulations to ensure they comply with both procedural and substantive legal requirements.
Publication Oversight: OAL manages the official publication of the California Code of Regulations (CCR) and the weekly California Regulatory Notice Register (CRNR).
Underground Regulation Determinations: OAL reviews petitions from the public challenging “underground regulations” which are rules enforced by state agencies that have not gone through the formal Administrative Procedure Act process.
Education and Training: OAL provides formal training to state agency personnel on the rulemaking process to ensure statewide compliance with the Administrative Procedure Act.
The Six Standards of Review by OAL
When the California Office of Administrative Law reviews a proposed regulation, it evaluates it against six specific legal standards mandated by the Administrative Procedure Act:
Authority: Does the state agency have the legal power to adopt the regulation?
Reference: Is there a specific statute or court decision that the regulation implements?
Consistency: Is the regulation in harmony with existing laws?
Clarity: Is the regulation written so that it can be easily understood by those it affects?
Nonduplication: Does the regulation avoid repeating existing state laws?
Necessity: Has the state agency provided substantial evidence demonstrating the need for the regulation?
The California Regulatory Rulemaking Process
State agencies typically follow one of two paths when proposing regulations:
Regular Rulemaking: Includes a formal 45-day public comment period. The Office of Administrative Law has 30 working days to review the final rulemaking record once submitted.
Emergency Rulemaking: Reserved for situations requiring immediate action to prevent serious harm. These regulations have an abbreviated review period, with the Office of Administrative Law having only 10 calendar days to make a decision.
Public Participation and Accountability
The California Office of Administrative Law ensures transparency by allowing the public to petition for the adoption or repeal of regulations. If OAL disapproves a regulation, it must issue a written decision explaining its reasoning. While OAL decisions can be appealed to the Governor, OAL itself does not have the power to substitute its own judgment for that of a rulemaking agency regarding the substantive content of a policy.
Contact us by phone or email to learn more about how we can help.